Capital Charges Reduced and Etheridge Sent to Prison with Possibility of Parole

Man who killed two women in Ogden ordered to prison

Salt Lake Tribune

Ogden ­• A judge on Monday ordered prison time for a Roy man who confessed to shooting two women to death in 2008, but not before a doctor and psychologist testified in court that the defendant might have carried out the crimes because he was in withdrawal from abruptly stopping anti-depressants.

Defense attorneys for Jacob D. Ethridge, 33, called the two witnesses prior to Ethridge’s sentencing in 2nd District Court, as evidence for the judge to consider before imposing Ethridge’s punishment. The two witnesses spoke about how six anti-depressant/anti-anxiety medications Ethridge had been taking could have influenced his behavior in the early-morning hours of July 13, 2008, when he shot 42-year-old Teresa ‘Wyoming" Tingey and 25-year-old RosaAnna Maria Cruz within 30 minutes of each other in Ogden.

Douglas Rollins, an expert in pharmacology, and Ronald Houston, a neuropsychologist, both testified that Ethridge could have been experiencing "hallucinations, delirium and general hostility" when he killed his victims as a result of stopping medication, in particular the anti-depressant Effexor, a month before the murders.

Houston said studies have shown that Effexor can cause people to display "depersonalization" or "where you feel unconnected to the world around you." Other side effects of the drug in some people include thinking abnormalities and abnormal judgment, he testified.

Prosecutors rebuked the witnesses’ testimony, arguing that Ethridge has a history of aggression that has led to several problems, including his discharge from the Marines.

Defense experts’ testimony — as well as a tearful apology and pleas for forgiveness from Ethridge — didn’t sway Judge W. Brent West from handing down a minimum 40-year prison term to Ethridge.

West ordered Ethridge to serve consecutive terms of 20 years to life in prison on each aggravated murder count. Ethridge also received a year in jail for assaulting a guard in a separate case filed after his arrest.

Before West handed down the sentence, forensic psychologist Stephen Golding — a rebuttal witness called by prosecutors — testified there is not sufficient scientific data to make a link between the drugs and Ethridge’s behavior. He said Ethridge likely has a borderline personality disorder, which could have influenced his emotions the day he killed the women. He also testified that Ethridge’s history of alcohol abuse could also have played a role in his decisions the night of the murder.

Ethridge told police during his confession that "alcohol gave me the courage" to kill the women, Golding said, citing a police report.

Prosecutors pointed out that Ethridge confessed to the murders and told Ogden police that he had fantasized about killing someone at random for a year prior to the attacks. When an Ogden police detective asked Ethridge if shooting the women fulfilled his fantasy, he replied, "It wasn’t what I expected. I didn’t expect to feel remorse and I do," Ethridge said, according to police reports.

Ogden police officer John Thomas, who sat with Ethridge at the police station after his confession, said that Ethridge appeared calm and matter-of-fact — not agitated from medication. Ethridge only became tearful when speaking about how committing the slayings would mean he can’t see his three children anymore.

Family members of Tingey spoke at Monday’s hearing about how the woman’s violent death has shaken their family. Two of Tingey’s brothers talked about the ups and downs the woman experienced before she landed on the streets working as a prostitute, Deputy Weber County Attorney Gary Heward said.

One of the brother’s told Ethridge, "I hope there is some good in you," Heward said. "He was not vengeful. He wanted to look Ethridge in the eye."

Family members of Cruz did not attend Monday’s hearing, but the judge read aloud a letter written describing their grief.

Ethridge in October pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree felony aggravated murder.

He confessed to Ogden police that he killed Tingey and Cruz.

Trece injunction remains in force as courts hear case

Tuesday November 2, 2010 in Standard Examiner

OGDEN -- The Utah Supreme Court's refusal to block an injunction labeling Ogden's oldest street gang a public nuisance is only the first of many hearings still expected to challenge it.
The high court heard arguments Oct. 25 on Ogden Trece's motion to lift the injunction pending arguments on its constitutionality.
The injunction ordered into law Sept. 27 by 2nd District Judge Ernie Jones bans gang members from associating with each other in public, being in the vicinity of guns, drugs or alcohol and staying out past an 11 p.m. curfew.
Common in California and used in a few other states, the injunction approach is a first for the state of Utah.
In a one-paragraph, three-sentence order signed Monday by Associate Justice Matthew Durrant and released Tuesday by state courts spokeswoman Nancy Volmer, the justices simply said a request for a stay of the injunction was denied.
They did not rule on any of the arguments about the injunction's constitutionality filed by the Weber County Attorney's Office or lawyers for Trece, including the ACLU of Utah.
As County Attorney Dee Smith explained, the justices are still mulling whether they will hear the appeals of the ACLU and others representing alleged Trece members.
The case now returns to 2nd District Court and oral arguments scheduled Nov. 9 before Jones on the constitutional questions raised about the injunction. Many of the defense concerns also are pending before the state Supreme Court, Smith said.
"A lot of the issues are before both courts," he said. "But neither court is likely to wait on the other." Smith said he also "fully expects" the injunction to be aired in a full-blown trial setting before Jones at some point.
The opposition, led by the ACLU and the Salt Lake law firm of Parr, Brown, Gee and Loveless, depicts the injunction as unconstitutional in that it "criminalizes legal behavior" in banning gang members' First Amendment rights of peaceable assembly. The injunction also has been called "over-broad" for making illegal the possession of felt-tip pens as graffiti tools.
Randy Richards, a veteran Ogden attorney who specializes in appeals law, recently joined the opposition, which includes local lawyers Michael Boyle and Michael Studebaker representing accused Trece members.
Richards was also Smith's law partner before Smith was named county attorney to replace Mark DeCaria, now a judge.
"He's got a client, and I represent the county," Smith said. "It's as simple as that."
The injunction has so far brought only a handful of arrests as police work first to individually serve the injunction personally on gang members, estimated to number between 330 and 485.
Trece was formed in 1974 under the name Ogden Knights, according to the 331-page injunction that includes more than 100 pages of photographs of gang tattoos, graffiti, hand signs and clothing, and accuses Trece of everything from graffiti and loud parties to running a car-theft ring and several murders.
The Knights moniker lasted about a year, dropped in favor of the tag "Centro City Locos," read the court papers, and Ogden Trece was adopted as the gang name in 1988.

Centro City Locos is making something of a comeback, CCL turning up in gang tattoos and graffiti, as well as the usual derivations of O13, Trece being Spanish for the number 13.

Trece is the home-grown gang of Ogden residents. Their chief rival gang includes many illegal aliens from Mexico and Los Angeles and often challenges the Ogden gang's "unauthorized" use of the word Trece, officials have said.

The number 13 has significance for the latter gang, referring to the 13th letter in the alphabet, M, tied to the Los Angeles-based Mexican Mafia.

Ethridge escapes death penalty

Thursday October 28, 2010 in Ogden Standard Examiner

OGDEN -- Jacob Ethridge was spared the death penalty Thursday by pleading guilty to aggravated murder charges in exchange for the prosecution setting aside execution as a penalty.
Sentencing is set for Dec. 13 where Ethridge, 32, faces two consecutive 20-years-to-life prison terms. The prosecution also agreed not to seek a life-without-parole prison term.
Ethridge murdered two women in the early morning hours of July 13, 2008, after walking the streets of Ogden "thinking about becoming a serial killer," Deputy Weber County Attorney Bill Daines said during Thursday's plea hearing. "This was not a spur of the moment decision."
The victims
Killed by single shots to the head were Teresa Rene Tingey, 43, and Rosanna Marie Cruz, 25. They both were prostitutes working Adams Avenue in the area of 26th and 24th streets who made the mistake of soliciting Ethridge.
In his confession hours after the slayings, released by authorities Thursday, Ethridge tells Ogden police detective Tim Scott he expected more of a thrill from the killings. "It wasn't what I expected. I didn't think I would feel remorse and I do."
His fantasies he'd had for about a year, describing them simply: "Walking down the street and shooting someone as they walk past me."
Lead defense counsel Randy Richards told 2nd District Judge W. Brent West he disagreed with Daines' interpretation of events, saying Ethridge's decision to stop taking his medication in the weeks prior was a bigger factor.
As part of the plea bargain, West agreed to set a Nov. 12 hearing at which two mental health experts will testify for the defense about Ethridge's psychological problems. Testimony also will cover the effects of going off his medication for his diagnosis, which has never been made public, except that it began at adolescence. The prosecution plans its own expert to testify in rebuttal.
An ex-Marine
In his confession, Ethridge told the detective he was a firearms expert, serving as a marksmanship instructor in the Marine Corps. Ethridge was in the Marine Corps shortly after graduating high school. How and why he left the service has never been disclosed.
Ethridge went to his parents' home in Roy after the early morning killings and confessed. His father drove him to the Ogden police station, where he also confessed. He has been held in Weber County Jail without bail since his arrest that morning.
Thursday's plea negotiation cancels a month-long trial that was set to begin Monday in Ogden's 2nd District Court.
Prosecutors and Ethridge's public defenders had been earnestly preparing for trial as late as Tuesday afternoon, when they huddled in West's courtroom to pare some 70 jurors from a roster of 200 who were to be called beginning Monday.
It was during that session that the plea negotiation became reality.
"We'd been talking off and on all along," Richards said. "Let's just say Tuesday we came together more seriously."
Deputy Weber County Attorney Gary Heward agreed Tuesday was the turning point.
He called prior plea discussions "very limited. The first realistic conversation we had came Tuesday."
The appeals factor
Heward said the thought of 20 years of appeals that typically accompanies a death penalty "figures into the decision absolutely" to forego execution.
"When Doug Lovell was sentenced to death in 1993, I predicted then that I'd be dead before he was," said Heward, who just turned 50.
The case of Lovell, 52, recently was ordered back to 2nd District Court for trial in the 1985 murder of Joyce Yost of South Ogden, even though Lovell pleaded guilty to the murders, described them on the stand, and led authorities on a fruitless five-week search to recover her body where Lovell said he had buried her in Ogden Valley.
Lovell's guilty pleas were vacated by the Utah Supreme Court because the judge taking his pleas in 1993 failed to advise Lovell he had the right to a public trial before an impartial jury.
Heward specifically made sure those two were added to the litany of questions asked of Ethridge in entering his guilty pleas Thursday.
"I applaud the prosecution," Richards said of the plea bargain. "It was a very reasonable solution."
He called the negotiation "a relief. The last three weeks I've been waking up at 3 a.m. wondering about this and worrying about that."
Avoiding the death penalty for Ethridge was the only victory he hoped for in the case, he said.
"Certainly in any capital case, the primary goal is to get out from under the death penalty," Richards said. "We knew we weren't going to win the case.
"He killed two people. We know that. We were going to admit that to the jury. He gave police the gun and his bloody clothes. He handed them the case on a silver platter.
"He shouldn't get off scot-free, and he isn't, but the thing is, this guy shouldn't die, plain and simple. The meds he was taking we now know have these kinds of side effects."
Ethridge makes the third defendant Richards has saved from death row in two years.
The first was Glenn Howard Griffin in 2008 in a Brigham City homicide, followed by Riqo Perea earlier this year in a gang-related double homicide. Both are serving life without parole prison terms.